Sunday, April 12, 2009

Offshore Zoning

In policy, the term "zoning" generally to the organizing of urban areas according to residential, commercial, or industrial function.  In other words, where zoning regulations have been implemented a factory can't be built among homes, etc.  The ecological and environmental justice implications of this type of zoning are somewhat contentious; keeping factories away from homes will protect the health of residents, however keeping businesses out of neighborhoods may mean that cars are required to do shopping.  A new type of zoning is being proposed in attempt to protect natural environments.  Instead of dealing with shops and neighborhoods, this type of zoning revolves around off-shore oil drilling and the ocean.  These regulations could protect marine wildlife and fisheries.  In order for these regulations to come into effect, however, the government may have to employ the public trust doctrine (http://www.nytimes.com/gwire/2009/04/10/10greenwire-zoning-rules-urged-to-protect-offshore-resourc-10509.html, accessed April 15, 2009).  The public trust doctrine applies to situations where natural resources and land are to be set aside for public use (for more on the public trust doctrine, see http://www.slc.ca.gov/Policy_Statements/Public_Trust/Public_Trust_Doctrine.pdf).  This doctrine could be used in order to protect areas of the ocean from offshore drilling.  In order to extend the doctrine to the ocean, President Obama will have to issue an executive order or it will have to be written into law by Congress (http://www.nytimes.com/gwire/2009/04/10/10greenwire-zoning-rules-urged-to-protect-offshore-resourc-10509.html, accessed April 15, 2009).

Friday, April 10, 2009

Supporting Alternatives

One of the most obvious routes out of our society's abusive relationship with petroleum is via alternative, renewable energy.  This kind of energy has a myriad of manifestations, from solar power to geothermal to fuel cell.  None of these forms of energy are "perfect" and bring up new problems to deal with.  However, most of them provide solutions to the most salient of the threats posed by petroleum dependency.  Part of the argument as to why alternative energy has had such a hard time establishing a dominant place in our economy is that it requires funding to work out its defects, and yet it can't get that funding until it works well enough to compete with the petroleum industry.

Valero Energy Corporation has just begun to lead investment in Terrabon LLC, a renewable energy company that hopes to convert biomass (organic waste) into a form that can be combined with gasoline.  Although hard-core environmentalists may feel that this is not enough, it seems to be a step in the right direction.  The CEO of Terrabon argues that it is a very important step, in fact, in the effort to meet the country's energy demands as well as Obama's criteria for renewable fuel levels for the near future (http://www.bizjournals.com/sanantonio/stories/2009/04/06/daily36.html, accessed April 10, 2009).  While in this case a corporation is funding efforts for renewable energy, many believe it is the responsibility of the government to provide ecological incentives through subsidies and cap-and-trade programs, for instance.

For more information on energy, fossil fuels, and alternative sources of power:
"The Energy Story": http://www.energyquest.ca.gov/story/index.html#table (aimed towards children)

"Alternative Energy": http://www.altenergy.org/

"U.S. Department of Energy: Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy": http://www.afdc.energy.gov/afdc/

Monday, April 6, 2009

Public Opinion

There is a constant debate over the effects of public opinion on today's politics.  Some have found direct statistical correlations between public opinion and government policy.  Others argue that these correlations may be due to external factors rather than government responsiveness.  At any rate, most politicians have hefty incentive to respond to public opinion if they hope to be re-elected or maintain successful political careers.  We can see response to public opinion in political campaigns of all sorts by looking at which aspects of an issue are emphasized.  For instance, within the topic of oil, campaigners are now focusing on its relationship to the economy, as opposed to, say, its relationship to the environment.  The current economic crisis means that issues surrounding jobs, trade, etc., are very important to the general public and more likely to win their sympathies.  For example, Hyperion Energy is presently hoping to build a new oil refinery in South Dakota .  Even though the recession makes the proposal seem unwise from various economic standpoints (lower demand for oil, tightening credit markets, etc.), the company is pushing the notion that the refinery will bring many new jobs to the area, thus stimulating the local economy (http://www.keloland.com/News/NewsDetail6371.cfm?Id=0,82950, accessed April 8, 2009).  Public opinion is very important to take into account when pushing policy, whether for or against the oil industry.  It becomes imperative that both sides take this into account if they wish to make cause succeed.

dcr0341l.jpg

Thursday, April 2, 2009

Civic Engagement and Civil Disobedience

One of the most salient features of an ideal democracy is the active participation of  citizens in their government.  The United States, despite not being what one would call an "ideal democracy", has traditionally boasted relatively high rates of civic engagement among its public.  Though rates of civic engagement have been significantly declining in the United States since the advent of technology (Bowling Alone by Robert Putnam), it is still not uncommon to hear of protests, grassroots campaigns, and various acts of civil disobedience.  The protests of the Alaskan fishermen against Exxon Mobil discussed in the last post are an example of this.

Last December, a young student from Utah engaged in an act of civil disobedience, as he called it, of his own.  Tim DeChristopher entered an auction of land for oil drilling and began outbidding everyone else in the room.  Naturally, he didn't have the money he was bidding.  Instead, he intended to make a statement and disrupt the auction, which he effectively did.  His primary concern in doing so was that the land being auctioned off was public land around the state's beautiful parks, including the famous Arches.
Yesterday, Tim DeChristopher was indicted for his actions.  If convicted, his sentence may be up to ten years in prison (http://blogs.wsj.com/environmentalcapital/2009/04/02/a-bid-too-far-utah-oil-lease-activist-tim-dechristopher-faces-jail-time/, accessed April 2, 2009).

While Tim faces a serious legal dilemma, his story demonstrates the impact a single individual can have in today's world.  It's not necessary for all of us to risk imprisonment in order to make a difference.  We all can affect public policy, including oil policy, by attending city council meetings, attending protests, writing letters to representatives, starting petitions, informing the community, and voting, to name a few.

Wednesday, March 25, 2009

Oil Spills and Corporate Power

File-OilSheenFromValdezSpill.jpeg

Part of what makes oil such a stable part of life in the United States is that the industry is run by corporations.  Having been granted personhood by a Supreme Court case in the late 1800s, corporations have immense power in the dynamics of politics and economics (http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/20090324_lessons_of_the_exxon_valdez/, accessed March25, 2009). Yet, unlike individuals, corporations generally do not suffer significant consequences from breaking the law.  Oil spills provide a prime example of this.  The picture above shows water affected by the March 24,1989 Exxon Valdez oil spill that occurred by Prince William Sound, Alaska (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exxon_Valdez_oil_spill, accessed March 25, 2009).  Consequent of this spill, "half a million seabirds died, along with 5,000 sea otters, 300 or so harp seals, and billions of young salmon, fish eggs and young juvenile fish" (http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/20090324_lessons_of_the_exxon_valdez/, accessed March 25, 2009).  

File-EVOSWEB_013_oiled_bird3.jpg

This environmental catastrophe not only had detrimental effects on wildlife, it also had terrible implications for the Alaskan population that was dependent on that wildlife.  The marine ecosystems that provided for fisheries and were the livelihood for countless fishermen is still in poor condition.  Although the affected individuals have been fighting ExxonMobil in court for the last twenty years, the oil corporation seems in fact to be winning the case.  This is a testimony to the immense power held by our nation's major companies, maintained through a combination of their financial advantage and their status as persons.  Today, those still fighting against the crime of two decades ago are claiming that it is imperative that corporations cease to be considered persons and that a constitutional amendment be made to establish this (http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/20090324_lessons_of_the_exxon_valdez/).  Clearly, with so much political influence something drastic will need to be done to become independent of the oil industry.

Thursday, March 12, 2009

Oil and the Recession

oil-price-economy.gif

The cartoon above refers to the part rising oil prices played in the fall of the economy this past year.  However, the relationship between oil prices and economics is a two-way street and now the recession is taking its toll on the oil industry.  With the economy suffering across the globe, demand for oil has dropped considerably.  For OPEC, this means that "the market is expecting a reduction, and if OPEC do not reduce, prices will fall" (http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601116&sid=arEWp.T2zwdQ&refer=africa, accessed March 12, 2009).  OPEC must now decide whether or not to cut oil exports in order to prevent prices from falling later in the year.  Although EIA (Energy Information Administration) forecasts made last summer predicted that OPEC's 2009 revenue would total about $1.3 trillion, most recent estimates have dropped to $383 billion.  While last year's revenue was a record $970 billion, the forecast for 2010 says OPEC will make $503 billion (http://www.reuters.com/article/GCA-Oil/idUSTRE5296Q320090310, accessed March 12, 2009).




Monday, March 2, 2009

Oil and International Economics

Our consumerism-based culture is one of the more obvious reasons for our high dependency on oil.  Other factors perhaps not as visible to the public eye play possibly even more significant roles in this.  For instance, international economics provide ample fuel for the United States oil industry.

Most of the oil in Europe is sent there from Russia via Ukraine.  Over the past several years, tension has risen and disputes have developed between Russia and Ukraine based primarily on questions of transit prices and gas debts.  Russia's response to these disagreements has been to reduce its export of oil supplies.  Consequently, Europe has suffered from significant gas cuts in the past year and especially earlier this year (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russia–Ukraine_gas_disputes).  This state of instability has piqued Europe's interest in exploring its own oil fields, which would require the use of United States drilling technology.  Consequently, European energy companies are investing huge sums of money in our oil business.  These billions of dollars could support development of technologies that would allow Europeans to uncover the potential of its own oil resources, such as shale which is extremely expensive and difficult to extract (http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2009/02/28/BUL2162BB0.DTL&type=tech).

European energy companies are making these substantial investments in the hopes of preventing massive energy crises.  However, if our dependence on oil continues, a global crisis is inevitable.  Granted, our culture will not be able to quit oil cold turkey and it will be important to utilize energy from oil while we transition off of it.  Yet, so little effort, money, and time is being devoted to the research and development of alternatives that one wonders if we will get on the wagon before its too late.  Imagine if those billions of dollars were invested in sustainable energy, education, and general cultural and technological devices to decrease our dependence on oil.  This would be a much stabler solution to Europe's oil woes.